Employers Banner Image

< Back to Hiring Manager Resources

Reviewing Candidate Applications

Most managers do not hire frequently enough to become experts in comparing candidates. When faced with several talented individuals it can be tough to find the right person for your team. However, hiring the wrong candidate may have a disastrous impact on your business.

Earlier, we mentioned that identifying whether you are hiring for potential, industry experience, or a manager, will play an important role when you start to review CVs. Refer to 'Job Description Writing & Tips' if you are still writing your job description. Although we highly recommend partnering with a recruitment expert, if you decide to recruit yourself, here are our tips on what to look for in a stand-out resume.

Hiring for potential

Hiring for 'potential' usually means that you are looking for a candidate with a marginal amount of experience or a transferrable skillset. You should also focus on finding someone who has a great attitude, work ethic, and communication skills. Whilst a CV is a good place to identify these characteristics, they will stand out more during an interview.

Hiring for industry experience

Hiring for industry experience generally means that you are looking for someone who already has relevant skills and experience, and is either after a new challenge or step in their career. To succeed, have a predefined list of criteria that include technical skills such as software or qualifications, industry experience, or specialist expertise. When you are reviewing your CVs, have this list to hand so you can highlight potential candidates that possess these skills, and warrant further screening via a telephone call.

Hiring a manager

If you are looking to fill a management position, you need to identify candidates who have a proven history for delivering results. Anyone who has carefully studied your advertisement or job description can tailor their CV to your requirements, but quantifiable results are much harder to fabricate. When reviewing candidate profiles, keep an eye out for examples where a candidate can clearly demonstrate their leadership qualities and previous achievements.

Do not forget the basics

There are some criteria you should always watch for irrespective of the calibre of candidate you are seeking to hire. Poor grammar, formatting, and spelling mistakes can all be indicators that a CV has been quickly thrown together with little attention. Some of the best candidates will also tailor their CVs for specific roles. This means you should be aware of whether you are reviewing a generic resume or a highly detailed and relevant CV, as a vague resume may show that the candidate has no real specific interest in your opportunity.

Struggling to screen hundreds of applications?

An unfortunate consequence of COVID is that most businesses have been inundated with hundreds of candidate applications for roles that would usually only receive several. If you are not prepared or lack the time to screen high volumes of candidates, we are happy to assist you with a standalone candidate screening and shortlisting service for a reduced fee. Contact us using the form on this page to learn more. 

< Previous Resource

Attracting Great Candidates

Next Resource >

Hiring Manager Interview Tips & Tricks